After another frustrating call to my running store to find that my shoes STILL has not come in, I took matters into my own hands and went to another store. DSW store of all places. I must have tried on every wide width shoe for slightly pronators and neutral runners. Unfortunately, most of the shoes in the store are medium widths.
I almost gave up until I found a pair of black Nike Air Pegasus+ that looked like it had a wider toe box. No wide widths at the store, so I picked up a half size larger and lo and behold they fit and they feeeeeeel good! I ran around the store to test them out. Crossing my fingers they work out. Grateful for DSW's return policy. Giddy over new running shoes! :)